Categorized | Local Business

Oven Fresh Treats: Sag Harbor Baking Co.

Posted on 16 December 2011

Sag Harbor Baking Company Fills the Gap

web_Sag Harbor Baking Co_7006

By Emily J. Weitz

Sag Harbor has the quiet charm of an old European village, and it’s what draws people from all over to stroll down Main Street and soak in its quaintness. The stress of preparing an evening dinner party is nearly vanquished when the shopping can all be done on foot, hustling from one shop to the next to gather cheese, wine and meats.

But that shopping trip was never quite complete, because there was nowhere to buy the fresh bread to accompany the wine and cheese. There was no local baker. Until now.

Rounding out the small town shopping experience, Sag Harbor Baking Company has opened its doors just in time for the holidays, and they’ve done it in a way that only two local girls could.

Mimi Yardley and Margaret Brooks, who have known each other since they were kids at Sag Harbor Elementary, decided to go into the bakery business not only because they both loved it, but because “We wanted to fill that gaping hole,” says Yardley. “This really makes Sag Harbor like a walking market,” adds Brooks. “You don’t have to just go to the supermarket for everything now.”

The two weren’t sure when they were going to open, and it took a lot of time to get their tiny, expertly organized kitchen up and running.

“Originally we were hoping to open in the summer,” says Yardley, and then they both laugh. “That didn’t happen, but it’s probably better this way. We’re able to get into a groove this way.”

Since they opened last week, they’ve already established a core group of loyal customers, not the least of whom are kids coming in after school for their treats. It helps that Yardley and Brooks, between their two families, have seven kids that span grades three to 11 in the Sag Harbor public schools.

“The kids come in for hot pretzel sticks,” says Yardley. “Or black and white cookies and other nostalgic bakery fare.”

The fresh, fluffy donuts are high on the kids’ lists, and Yardley likes to guess what kind they want when they come in.

“Chocolate frosting with rainbow sprinkles?” she asks her own son, whose mouth curls into an anticipatory grin.

But it’s not only the young contingent that’s already hooked on the bakery.

“We’ve only been open for a week,” says Yardley, “and already we’ve had one guy come in every day to get his regular.”

On a chilly Saturday morning, there’s a buzz to the bakery and the door never stays closed for long. One customer comes in from the cold to peruse the bounty of pastries and muffins and decides “My kids would love… All of these I’m sure.”

She settles on a bran muffin with apricots and ginger for herself and some lindzer tarts to bring home.

Another customer loads up on lemon squares, two fresh baked focaccias, and a few slices of flourless chocolate cake. Everything, including the focaccia, is baked in-house, except for the loaves of bread.

“Our kitchen is teeny tiny,” explains Brooks, “so we didn’t have space for a bread oven. Any breads we can bake in a conventional oven we do.” Other breads are brought in fresh every morning.

Brooks has been in the business of baking for a long time. After graduating from Pierson, she left Sag Harbor and moved to California.

“I worked as a pastry chef in restaurants and bakeries in California for 20 years, and I came back six years ago,” she said.

Yardley was in a different industry entirely, working as a CPA and an accountant.

“But baking has always been something I really loved,” she says. “It’s very rewarding. We do a lot of special occasion baking, where we feel like we’re celebrating with people. Baking makes people happy.”

Some of the more rewarding projects they’ve had include a series of cakes for a 100th birthday and a cake to celebrate a successful heart transplant.

“For the three month anniversary of the transplant, we baked a low-salt heart-shaped cake,” says Yardley.

Special occasions abound this time of year, and Yardley and Brooks plan to put in plenty of hours in their little kitchen. With traditional yule log (Buche de Noel) sponge cakes, eggnog cheesecakes, holiday cookie platters and lots of other seasonal treats in addition to their regular offerings, they should be very busy delivering the holiday cheer.

“It’s a great time to be opening,” says Yardley.

Brooks adds, “We’re just looking forward to being a part of the community.”

Be Sociable, Share!

This post was written by:

- who has written 3074 posts on The Sag Harbor Express.

Contact the author

12 Responses to “Oven Fresh Treats: Sag Harbor Baking Co.”

  1. Spikeland says:

    Good luck ladies!!!

  2. Sandi Kruel says:

    I know both of these great women (for a long time)
    and have had the pleasure of tasting their sweets… I wish them much success and cant wait to watch two local girls succeed!!! I will be in soon….

  3. Brigid Collins says:

    Their treats are delectable and their enthusiasm a delight! Wishing these lovely ladies much success! I continue to hear rave reviews around town!

  4. Anne Van Couvering says:

    What lovely news – they’re right, it was always a gaping hole in Sag Harbor, to not have a bakery. As someone who can’t eat wheat anymore, I’m hoping that they’ll experiment with some gluten-free recipes once they get established. Best of luck!!!

  5. Good luck ladies…..will be in soon!!!!

  6. Marian McMahon says:

    What a beautiful little bakery. My sister and I stopped in and LOVED the gluten free choices, the brownies are amazing! Thank you for offering gluten free baked goods, and we look forward to seeing you soon!!

  7. Steven Monzeglio says:

    Great addition to village of Sag Harbor! Wonderful baked goods right on Division Street……I’ll be in for those great black and white cookies!

  8. Becky Jobes says:

    Just watched Barefoot Contessa episode….featuring coconut layer cake from Sag Harbor Bakery. Do you ship?
    Do you have website?

  9. Wmjindsm says:

    Went to the website on their sign in the episode and it’s not active. It was

  10. Brandi says:

    Why do they not have a site ? Are they still in business ? Mail order available ? HELP !!!

  11. Gwen Jones says:

    Saw your beautiful coconut cake on today’s episode of Barefoot Contessa. Looked delicious! Want to know if you have a site for ordering. Wishing you much success.

  12. Michela Butts says:

    The ladies are working on there website now and it will launch soon! Currently, they are not shipping cakes but after this barefoot contessa show they might need to start, yum! Mimi & Margaret are excited to spend there second summer at the bakery and can fill special orders about a week in advanced by calling (631)899-4900
    Thanks everyone! From, the counter girl :)

Leave a Reply

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off-topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Terms of Service