East End Baymen Call for Fishermens’ Bill of Rights; Consider Lawsuit

Posted on 05 July 2012


Paul Lester and Daniel Rodgers

Standing in a Riverhead law office on Tuesday afternoon, about a dozen of East End fishermen signed a Fisherman’s Bill of Rights. It was the latest move in a months long effort by a group of East Hampton baymen to protect their industry against what they say are unreasonable practices by the state that take away their basic rights under the Constitution.

Daniel Rodgers, a Riverhead attorney who has taken up the East End fisherman’s battle against the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), said he plans to forward the Fisherman’s Bill of Rights to Governor Andrew Cuomo and the Secretary of State.

This comes after Rodgers formally filed an ethics complaint against the DEC related to the sale of fishermen’s catch after DEC officers seized the fish.

Nassau County attorney Harry H. Kutner, Jr. also announced this week that the group is considering a federal civil rights class action lawsuit against the DEC for allegedly violating fishermen’s rights on the East End.

Rodgers has been working with baymen like the Lester family, current East Hampton Town Trustee Nat Miller and former trustee and veteran baymen Stuart Vorpahl since he took on a DEC case against the Lesters last summer. Paul and Kelly Lester were accused of violating the state’s Conservation Law after a raid of their Amagansett home and were ultimately acquitted. However, for Rodgers it opened his eyes to what he views as state law that allows DEC officers to deprive fishermen of their basic rights under the Constitution. Specifically, it allows that fishermen’s homes and boats can be searched without a warrant and fish seized and sold by DEC officers before they have been deemed guilty or innocent of any crime.

“Because it is the law of the land in the State of New York that fishermen and women as a class be treated differently than ordinary citizens of this State, we have created a Fishermen’s Bill of Rights as an Amendment to the Constitution of the State of New York,” said Rodgers in a statement on Tuesday.

Under the Fishermen’s Bill of Rights, all fishermen would be protected against warrantless searches and seizures unless an officer has probable cause. Fishermen cannot be deprived of property without due process, under the bill of rights and if they are they must be compensated. The bill of rights also aims to give fishermen equal protection under the law and protects them from excessive penalties.

Lastly, the bill of rights states that “No fisherman shall be subject to any moratorium” that deprives them of the right to work unless it is backed up by actual legislation by the state. Currently, the DEC has moratoriums against issuing fluke and striped bass permits to fisherman.

“The DEC moratoriums effectively close down fisheries,” said Rodgers on Tuesday. “It deprives fisherman the ability to make a living. Moratoriums are designed to be temporary but these have been in place for years.”

These issues, said Rodgers, will also be addressed if and when a lawsuit is filed on behalf of the fishermen against the DEC, which could happen as early as August, he said.

Be Sociable, Share!

This post was written by:

- who has written 2529 posts on The Sag Harbor Express.


Contact the author

4 Responses to “East End Baymen Call for Fishermens’ Bill of Rights; Consider Lawsuit”

  1. D. DeRosa says:

    The DEC is like the gestapo, or worse, the SS.
    They have full control over anything and everything relating to the water and 200 from it. It’s tyranny. Our forefathers never envisioned the government being so intrusive and micro managing our lives the way they do now. Land of the free? Not anymore.

  2. low Tide says:

    “…it is the law of the land in the State of New York that fishermen and women as a class be treated differently than ordinary citizens of this State,” ????

    Good definition of hubris! Somehow and I mean no disrespect, I tend to think of our local fishermen and women the embodiment of ordinary citizens.

  3. CW Vasold says:

    Just pray that NOAA dosen’t get involved or CCA who can’t make up their minds. When they are not closing areas they just limit the seasons and creel.


Leave a Reply

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off-topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Terms of Service

Follow The Express…


Pictures of the Week - See all photos