Parking Dominates Sag Harbor Library Debate

Posted on 30 April 2010

web library

Just a handful of residents in a crowded Sag Harbor Planning Board meeting Tuesday night offered suggestions to the board about John Jermain Memorial Library’s plan to double the size of its historic Main Street structure, with parking the main issue of debate.

On Tuesday, April 27 the board held a special public session on JJML’s plans to restore and expand its Main Street location — the goal not to debate the project’s merits, but rather give the public the chance to tell the planning board what they would like to see the village review about the project.

After years, and several revisions, residents of the Sag Harbor school district approved close to $10 million in funding last summer for a 7,725 square-foot expansion of the 7,084 square foot library, twwhich will be developed at the library’s current site. The three-story, modern addition, made of glass, masonry and stainless steel is proposed to wrap around the rear of the building, in what architects describe as a chevron shape.

Seemingly anticipating that parking and traffic would be the issue of the hour, after a brief presentation on the architectural style of the addition by architect Richard Munday, the library’s environmental planner David Emilita walked the crowd of 60 residents through their parking plan.

Sag Harbor Village’s zoning code’s formula for determining the amount of parking needed at the library uses the floor area devoted to seating, the floor area devoted to books and how many employees the library has on staff. Emilita said the existing library, under that formula would need 56 spaces.

“Of course, as you know, there are none,” he said. “Potentially a big problem.”

The expansion would necessitate an additional 28 spaces for a grand total of 84 parking spaces, said Emilita. However, using a standard method for parking calculations – outlined in a manual published by the Institute of Traffic Engineers – the library would only need 61 parking spaces and after conducting its own surveys at JJML, Emilita believes they need even less.

Based on surveys conducted in 2003 and 2009, Emilita said the number of patrons that come to the library by car has dropped by two-thirds in the last six years, and the number of patrons that bike to JJML has more than doubled.

“We see today that in 2009, one-third of library patrons get to the library, but they are not seeking parking,” said Emilita. He added, two-thirds of library patrons are not just visiting JJML when they come to the village, but also attending to other business in Sag Harbor.

Based on a peak traffic analysis conducted Labor Day weekend last year, Emilita said a survey of public parking in a two-to-three block radius, or 800-feet, around JJML showed two-thirds of parking spaces were vacant. While the spaces are not officially striped for parking, Emilita said his team has surveyed the area and found there are 231 parking spaces within walking distance to JJML. Emilita added, accounting for public activities in the neighborhood, as well as fire hydrant areas, houses that require on-street parking and driveways, his team estimates there would be 112 vacant spaces at peak hours around the existing library.

“Having done all that analysis, I believe the library expansion can take place with some sort of striping program to be implemented and we will explore that with the village,” said Emilita.

Sag Harbor resident Jim Posner was not swayed by Emilita’s figures.

“I think it is sort of an insult to the population that we can say in reality that there is parking when there is no parking,” said Posner.

Posner argued that 50 percent of JJML patrons are from outside of the Village of Sag Harbor, and require parking when they come to the library. He also said that libraries in Hampton Bays, Southampton and Riverhead all have dedicated parking outside of their building “in a civilized way.”

Gigi Morris, who lives on Main Street just a block from the library, disagreed with Posner’s assessment. Remembering an early meeting about the addition, held at the library to a standing room only crowd, Morris said there was not a single car parked in front of her house that evening.

“I almost have never had a car parked in front of my house for something happening at the library,” said Morris.

A member of the 725-GREEN movement, which just brought in Project for Public Spaces to Sag Harbor, Morris said parking should not be the focus of the library’s expansion plan and that organization would agree.

“They would say quite adamantly, when you plan for parking you lose every vision of making it a place you want to be,” she said. “As they said to me, you have to get your mind out of the gutter, and if you create a place, a place people want to be, where they can go to the library, the museums, the village, they will find a way to go there.”

Mac Griswold, another Sag Harbor resident, said she wondered if the planners and architects could illuminate the public on safety measures for parking around the library.

“The perception there isn’t enough parking arises from the safety of the parking,” she said.

Outside of parking, there was a lone comment from the person likely most affected by the library’s expansion plan — neighbor Ann Costaldo, whose Jefferson Street home would sit directly behind the new addition. Costaldo had remained mum on the project until Tuesday night.

“What has me really baffled by the whole thing is they are going to squeeze this on a little property when there is a perfectly good building next door,” said Costaldo, referring to the former Morpurgo property directly behind the library on Union Street, which has been shuttered since its court-mandated sale.

Costaldo said the library should spend an additional $1 million to $2 million to buy that property and erect the addition there – an idea floated years ago, which led to litigation that continues to this day by the former owner of the property, Anselm Morpurgo.

“It’s a danger to the community,” said Costaldo of the Morpurgo property. “Why couldn’t they just raze that building and use that for the library? Can anyone answer me?”

Be Sociable, Share!

This post was written by:

- who has written 3004 posts on The Sag Harbor Express.

Contact the author

8 Responses to “Parking Dominates Sag Harbor Library Debate”

  1. Sally Booth says:

    The presentation of the new plans was impressive! The architect and parking expert were comprehensive in their explanations. The plans for the new building are creative and work to celebrate the wonderful architecture of the original John Jermain Library. Librarian Cathy Creedon, her ever-helpful staff, and the library board should all be commended for commitment and hard work they have put into this project to make this very important public institution even more of an anchor in our town.

  2. saggish says:

    Sorry to be blunt, but Emilita is smoking a lot of dope. Why would you do a parking survey on Labor Day weekend? Why would you survey in a radius of 2-3 miles around the library? That makes no sense. If the 7-11 wanted to expand, would people accept a parking survey of spaces 3 miles away? If Mr. Emilita wants to post his survey and methodology, I would be happy to look at it. But on its face, it is self-serving and intentionally misleading.
    Other than that, we’re good to go!

  3. Dear “Saggish”
    Thank you for your comments. The library selected Labor Day intentionally: It is one of the busiest weekends in Sag Harbor in terms of traffic, and we felt that the traffic counts, and available parking assets during that period would be more meaningful than numbers gathered at another time, for example in late January. We did not, in fact, conduct the study in a two to three mile radius, rather in an 800′ radius, or roughly two to three blocks. All of the numbers discussed at the Planning Board meeting were based on those calculations. I’m not sure how the two to three mile concept worked its way into the Express article, but I will arrange to have the parking study posted on our website. In the meantime I have the full report in my office, and am happy to share with you if you’d like to stop by.

    Best Wishes,
    Catherine Creedon
    John Jermain Memorial Library
    201 Main Street
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    631.725.0049 x23

  4. Elementary School Parent #1 says:

    If we could finally just demolish the eyesore that is the former Bulova Watch Factory and create large parking lot for the entire town so we could finish with these parking arguments. Also, once we have all this new parking let’s change all parking on Main Street to parallel parking, so we all don’t have to wait for one of the fake summer cops to stop traffic for us to get out of our space.

  5. Lamar says:

    The town has done little over the years to secure adequate parking. Business owners constantly loose business because people can’t find parking. A two tiered garage on the present lot behind town would be a good start but will never happen. The watch case factory is privately owned and would be a wonderful asset today if not for some morons in this town that came out like escaped lunatics to fight vehemently against it and succeeded long enough for the economy to collapse. It is not available for public parking and when it was available the town passed on it. The fake summer cops are just kids taking summer jobs. I love this town and thank god I am lucky enough to live here. Most of our incidental problems are the result of bad decisions made many years ago by people who lacked forward vision. We have not changed much since the 1940’s but that is what some love most. Interestingly enough in the years to come library’s will be of little use to most of us as every book will be available digitally on a little screen you can carry around with you. I wonder what the future use of the building will be when print books go the way of vinyl records. Maybe they can turn it into a parking lot. Just kidding.

  6. Kathryn Menu says:

    I have made a correction in the story – it should have read that the parking study encompassed a two to three block radius, not two to three mile radius. We apologize for the mistake and a correction will appear in this Thursday’s edition of The Sag Harbor Express.

  7. The Library’s full parking study is now available on our blog; follow the link on or go directly to
    And, as always, feel free to contact me for more information:
    Catherine Creedon
    John Jermain Memorial Library
    201 Main Street
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    631.725.0049 x23

  8. I have a vested interest and have followed this project since its inception as my family roots are large and wide in Sag Harbor. Being a ‘Proxy grandchild’ of the late Nancy Willey ( Cousin Nan) and with direct linage with the Cooper ( Starr Gardnier Cooper Collection in library) and Dominey families keeping this library as a contributing structure, and cultural resource to the fabric of Sag Harbor is vital. . In regarding parking a new urbanism approach with code form based planning decisions need to be made regarding the parking issue. Naturally a convenient store with corporate interest will balk at the idea of granting local favoritism with a site specific change to the land use code. So what.The merits of this structure being adaptively reused and remaining a vital contributing resource far out weigh a “chain store”. Your report shows how the SH culture is changing back to a more pedestrian friendly client. People have found ways to handle the parking issue in the past and they will in the future.
    Cousin Nan would remark about the traffic and noise pollution and is the reason for the Rosa Rugosas and wisteria in front of the house for so many years before the Sag Harbor Historical Society received the building. I had to remind Cousin Nan that with her preservation efforts and historic house tours that she and others created a desirable atmosphere in Sag Harbor which is attracting the attention and desire to relocate and experience the village. Due to Historic Preservation efforts the beauty of the village has survived.

Leave a Reply

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off-topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Terms of Service

Follow The Express…

Pictures of the Week - See all photos